Skip to Content

Butterfinger Cookie Dough Brownies!

Butterfinger Cookie Dough Brownies!

Sharing is caring!

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #mixinmoments#CollectiveBias

Butterfinger Cookie Dough Brownies2 

Butterfingers, Cookie Dough, and Brownie mix combine to leave you with a decadent treat that’s chocolaty, peanut-buttery, and oh so good. Butterfinger cookie dough brownies are the perfect baked goodie for anyone who loves peanut butter and chocolate. Bonus: They’re super easy to make!

Baking & More Mixes

Cookies and brownies are a favorite in our house and I typically use a boxed mix because they’re good and they’re easy to whip up. When I saw that Tollhouse has new baking mixes, Brownies & More and Cookies & More, I knew I had to try them out. Plus, I’m long overdue to make some baked treats for my family. Since they all love butterfingers I whipped them up a batch of Butterfinger cookie dough brownies. I love cookie dough brownies, and this is just a kicked version with chunks of real Butterfingers.

For this recipe I’m using the new baking mixes from Tollhouse, Brownies & More with Butterfingers and Cookies & More with Butterfingers. Made with no artificial preservatives the Brownies & More mixes allow you a delicious way to make a variety of treats. The back of the box has a few different recipe ideas and you can find more on The Tollhouse Baking & More mixes can be found in Kroger stores in the baking aisle next to all the baking mixes.

Cookies & More Butterfingers

Now let’s get started baking. This recipe is very easy to throw to together and requires only a few ingredients that I’m sure you already have in your home. You’ll need the Brownies & More with Butterfingers mix and Cookies & More with Butterfingers mix. The food thing about this recipe is you could also use the Brownies & More with Chocolate Morsales instead of the Butterfinger mix, if you wanted less Butterfinger, but who wants that? First you’ll make both of your mixes per the box directions. Next grease or line an 8 inch baking pan and pour in your brownie mix. Then you’ll take a cookie scoop (or a spoon will work) and you’ll drop balls of cookie dough into the brownie mix. Then you’ll bake at 325 for about 40 minutes.

Butterfinger Bits

Brownies & More Butterfingers

Cookie Dough Brownies

Butterfinger Cookie Dough Brownies

Butterfinger Cookie Dough Brownies1

Cookie Dough Brownies1

Once the cookie dough brownies are done, let them cool, cover them with chocolate frosting (any will do), cut them up, and ENJOY!

Happy Boy with Brownies

Right now when you buy a box of Brownies & More you can take advantage of this Ibotta offer to earn .75$ when you join and buy a box of Nestle Toll House Brownies and More mixes.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tammy Horn

Sunday 14th of January 2018

Oh yum!! These look sooo good. I must try these, I bet they wouldn't last long around here.

shelly peterson

Wednesday 16th of November 2016

These brownies look really good. I love brownies and Butterfinger so I know I would love these.


Friday 4th of November 2016

We are always looking for different treats to prepare the grandkids...and me!

Julie Wood

Wednesday 2nd of November 2016

Your BUTTERFINGER COOKIE DOUGH BROWNIES recipe is amazing and I need to make these for a Holiday dessert. I have been looking for a dessert and this is it! Thanks for sharing.


Thursday 27th of October 2016

I bet these would be great with a scoop of ice cream on top, with a heavy dose of caramel syrup.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.